top of page


It's more than just a name. It represents the many groups of people with common interests and goals we are proud to serve. Find out what it means to be in our COMMUNITY.

White Feather


2 CIG-AO 2019 Top 10 Poster - OH.PNG
2 CIG-AO 2019 Top 10 Poster - OH_crop.PN



Comprehensive programs. Extraordinary service. Customer focused.

Why do business with us?

We are 100% independent and give you the freedom to choose from multiple insurance companies and a wide range of products. We aren’t locked in to a single company like many other agents. This means you get a plan that fits your needs and budget, instead of having to settle for a cookie-cutter policy that’s not right for you.


Our core values

We understand that it’s important for you to partner with a company that shares your values, which is why Community Insurance Group is clear and upfront with ours.

Community Insurance Group, Ltd. is part of Higginbotham, one of the nation’s largest independent insurance, financial and HR services firms trusted by thousands of businesses, individuals and families to protect what matters most to them. Higginbotham provides a single source solution through a unified group of regional offices with global capabilities.

As a Higginbotham Partner, Community Insurance Group offers all the resources that differentiate the group, paired with the personal service that further distinguishes us.

Because when you lead with values, value leads. Read about our partnership. Visit Higginbotham.


You trust us in times of greatest need and that’s not something we take for granted. We hold ourselves to the highest standards of ethics, accountability and compliance.


We don’t view insurance as a product. We see it as a relationship. And just like any strong, positive relationship, we build ours on empathy, compassion, trust and dignity.


We take our work seriously, and will continue to serve you in the best way possible. That’s why we’re fortunate that so many of our clients choose us, stay with us and recommend us.



Aw, shucks. We’re blushing.
We might be biased, but we think our service is pretty great. Our customers think so too.



Our full-service agency has been doing it right for 25 years. We pay special attention to your needs, pride ourselves on delivering consistent, outstanding results, and adhere to strict ethical and legal guidelines. Browse our service areas to learn more about how we can help you.

Areas of Expertise




We don’t believe in average.
We strive for being remarkable in everything we do.


What to expect when you work with us

We provide you with more options and greater flexibility. You can choose from a wide range of companies to find the best coverage at the best price. And when you’re working with us, you don’t have to make sense of your options alone. You have a partner and an advocate making recommendations that align with your needs.

You talk, we listen


The first thing we’ll do is schedule a chat with one of our Personal Risk Managers. Tell us all about you – your family, interests, passions, goals, concerns and anything else. Throw all of your questions at us.

Come up with the best solution


With all due respect to Nike, we never “just do it.” While that may be a great strategy for starting a workout routine, it’s no way to think about managing your risk. So we think about it first. A lot.

This is where the magic happens


We put pen to paper (more accurately, fingers to computer) and develop a program that gives you peace of mind and the most value for your insurance dollar.

We’re there when you need us


Your needs change over time, and we’re there with you every step of the way to make sure your coverage is up-to-date. Insurance should be the last thing on your mind, because it’s the first thing on ours.

Our Vision

We envision successful client relationships based on proven,

valued solutions from highly trained and empowered agency associates.

Community is not just a name, as it also represents

where we work, live and give through our actions and commitments; truly…


“Embracing what it means to be Community




Take the first step
and we’ll take it from there.
Let's start a conversation

You’re not going to hear a ridiculously long automated phone menu when you call us. Your email isn’t going to the inbox abyss, never to be seen or heard from again. At Community Insurance Group, we provide the exceptional service we’d want to experience ourselves.


We strive to provide the best service possible with every contact!

We operate in an industry built on trust. This can only be achieved through communication and experienced support – from the first contact to your ten-year anniversary.


At Community, you always talk to a human

Have questions about insurance? Our entire team receives specialized training regularly to ensure you’re receiving the best information possible. From basic questions to complex compliance inquiries, we’re here to help!

Interested in learning more about our services? Our Account Executives take the time to discuss your existing insurance program and help you make smart decisions that best meet your needs.


If you need immediate assistance, please call 1-800-846-6040.
Sidney Office

2621 Michigan Street
Sidney, Ohio 45365
Phone: 937.492.0823

Minster Office

68 West Fourth Street

Minster, OH 45865

Phone: 419.628.2114

Fort Loramie Office

408 South Main Street

Fort Loramie, OH 45845

Phone: 937.295.2422

Hours of Operation: 

Monday-Friday 8:00 am - 5:00 pm

Success! Message received.

bottom of page