If you are ever unable to reach our office to report a claim during severe weather, we welcome you to contact your insurance company and report your claim directly. Below are the phone numbers and websites for the companies we represent.

Of course you may also contact our Claims Manager, Jenny Davidson (937) 492-0823 jenny@communityinsurancegroup.com

You can also find a list of our companies’ claims websites on the Community Insurance Group Website.

Call or Click Name Below to Report a Claim Online

Acuity – 800-242-7666  

Auto-Owners 800-252-4626

EMC – 888-362-2255

Frankenmuth – 800-234-4433

Grange – 800-445-3030

Liberty Mutual 800-362-0000

Motorists -800-876-8766

Ohio Mutual 800-686-3011 Option 6

Progressive – 800-776-4737

Safeco – 800-332-3236

Utica National – 800-216-1420

West Bend – 877-922-5246